Short answer. Stay on Braintrust if the eval workflow, playground and dataset experience are the centre of your release process. Choose Langfuse for a self-hostable all-rounder, Arize Phoenix for a local-first OpenTelemetry workbench, Opik for test suites and agent debugging, or an OpenTelemetry plus ClickHouse stack if you want one observability plane and will build the eval layer yourself. Helicone is a gateway and log tool first, not an eval-first platform.
What Braintrust does well
Braintrust combines tracing, datasets, experiments, scoring, playgrounds and human review. The unit is the experiment: run a dataset, score outputs, compare to a baseline, promote the winner. That fits AI product teams better than a generic APM tool with an LLM plugin.
Starter is $0/month with $10 of credits, 1 GB processed data, 10,000 scores and 14-day retention. Pro is $249/month with $100 of credits, 5 GB, 50,000 scores and 30-day retention. Overage is $4/GB and $2.50/1,000 scores on Starter, or $3/GB and $1.50/1,000 on Pro. Enterprise adds custom retention, SSO, RBAC, a BAA and an uptime SLA.
The lock-in is not prompt text. It is trace IDs, dataset versions, evaluator definitions, scores and historical comparisons that make a release defensible. Audit those before choosing a replacement.
The six alternatives
| Option | Deploy and license | Eval workflow | Tracing | Price anchor |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Langfuse | Open-source core; cloud or self-host | Datasets, experiments, LLM-as-judge, human annotation | OTel and SDKs | Free Hobby; Core $29/mo; Pro $199/mo; Enterprise $2,499/mo |
| Arize Phoenix | Open source (Elastic License 2.0); self-host or Arize AX | Experiments, evals, playground | OpenTelemetry-native | Phoenix free; AX Free $0; AX Pro $50/mo |
| LangSmith | Cloud; Enterprise self-host/hybrid | Offline and online evals, annotation queues | SDK and OTel | Developer $0; Plus $39/seat/mo |
| Opik | Open source; cloud or self-host | Test suites, assertions, 30+ metrics, agent playground | SDK and OTel | Free OSS and free cloud tier; paid plans at signup |
| Helicone | Open source; cloud or self-host | Basic scores and experiments | Proxy-based request logs | Hobby free; Pro $79/mo; Team $799/mo |
| OpenTelemetry + ClickHouse/Grafana | Open standards; self-host or managed | Bring your own eval runner | OTel collector and spans | Infrastructure plus engineering time |
Feature labels are a planning summary. Licenses, free-tier limits and plan inclusions change; verify each vendor's current documentation and terms.
CI integration: the release gate test
A tool is an eval platform only if it can fail a build. The pattern: a fixed dataset, a scorer or judge, a baseline, and a threshold that blocks promotion. Braintrust's CLI and SDK fit that loop. Langfuse supports experiments through its SDK and UI; Phoenix has a Python eval library and pytest workflows; Opik has test suites and assertions; LangSmith has datasets and runs. Helicone can log and score, but it is not an eval-first gate.
Two checks matter more than the feature list: can CI run without a human clicking a dashboard, and can it produce a machine-readable diff a reviewer can audit? If not, it is a dashboard, not a gate.
Dataset portability
Export dataset items and expected outputs, the evaluator prompt or code, score names and scales, trace IDs, model and prompt versions, and run timestamps. The hard part is preserving the link between a score and the exact input, prompt, model and parameters.
Braintrust exposes datasets and experiments through its SDK/API; S3 export is Enterprise, not Starter or Pro. Confirm format, retention and rate limits. Langfuse has a public API and batch export; Phoenix is local-first, so the database and trace files are yours under the Elastic License. Opik and Helicone have open-source editions, but test a round-trip.
Migrate one high-value eval suite first, not all history. Re-run it and compare pass/fail decisions. If they diverge, the evaluator changed, not just storage.
Price at volume
The plans use different billing units. Braintrust charges processed data and scores; Langfuse charges billable units (trace, observation or score); Arize charges spans and ingestion; Helicone charges requests and storage; LangSmith charges seats plus traces. Normalise to the same month of traffic.
Example: 2,000,000 trace events/month
Langfuse Pro:
$199 + ((2,000,000 - 100,000) / 100,000) × $8
= $199 + 19 × $8 = $351
Braintrust Pro:
$249 + data overage (5 GB included, then $3/GB)
+ score overage (50,000 included, then $1.50/1,000)
Model both lines; event count alone is not enough.
Helicone Pro: $79 + usage-based request and storage charges
Arize AX Pro: $50, but overage is a custom/enterprise conversation
"Braintrust is $249" is not a cost comparison. Long prompts and heavy scoring can cost more in overages than plan fees; light scoring with long retention may suit a self-hosted option where storage is your object-store bill. For the wider framework, see accuracy, latency and cost.
Migration checklist
- Freeze a baseline. Export the current eval suite and record its pass/fail decisions.
- Map the data model. Trace, span, dataset item, experiment, score and annotation are not the same object in every tool.
- Re-create evaluators. Port prompts and code, then test for drift in the judge.
- Re-instrument with OpenTelemetry where possible; it makes the next migration cheaper.
- Run both systems in parallel for a sample of production traffic and compare completeness.
- Set retention and sampling before cutover; both are cost drivers.
If you are also consolidating model access, keep the layers separate: the model API is not the eval platform. Plugsky provides OpenAI-compatible inference and usage analytics, not tracing or dataset management. See what Plugsky logs.
When to stay on Braintrust
- Your team already runs experiments as the primary release ritual.
- You value the playground, dataset and human-review experience more than self-hosting.
- Your trace volume and score volume fit inside Pro, or you can negotiate Enterprise.
- You need a vendor with an uptime SLA and a BAA on Enterprise.
If self-hosting, OpenTelemetry or a lower trace-storage bill is the priority, start with Langfuse or Phoenix. If you are already standardized on LangChain, compare the LangSmith alternatives before switching twice.
FAQ
What is the best Braintrust alternative for evals?
Langfuse is the closest all-round substitute for tracing, prompts and evals with self-hosting. Phoenix is better for a local-first OTel workbench; Opik for test suites and agent debugging. Braintrust remains the most polished eval-first workflow.
Is Braintrust free?
Starter is $0/month with $10 credits, 1 GB processed data, 10,000 scores and 14-day retention. Pro is $249/month with $100 credits, 5 GB, 50,000 scores and 30-day retention. Overage is $4/GB and $2.50/1,000 scores on Starter, or $3/GB and $1.50/1,000 on Pro.
Can I export my Braintrust datasets?
Plan export before migrating. Braintrust exposes datasets and experiments through its SDK and API; S3 export is listed as Enterprise, not Starter or Pro. Confirm format, retention and rate limits, then test a round-trip.
Does Braintrust work in CI?
Yes. Braintrust has a CLI and SDK for running evals, so a deploy can fail on a score threshold. Langfuse, Phoenix, Opik and LangSmith support similar dataset-and-baseline gates; run a fixed dataset and fail on regression.
Is Plugsky an alternative to Braintrust?
No. Plugsky is an OpenAI-compatible model API, not a tracing or eval platform. Use Plugsky for inference and Braintrust or an alternative for traces, datasets and release gates.
Sources: Braintrust pricing, Langfuse pricing, Phoenix repository and Helicone pricing, checked 20 November 2026. Features and licenses change; verify before purchase. This page is editorial and does not rank providers by payment.