---
name: wutt-user-journey
slug: plugsky--wutt-user-journey
description: "Use when auditing Wutt.net (run your business on WhatsApp & Telegram) \u2014 full client onboarding journey, packages/plans and what each client receives, every client-area page, subscriptions and renewals, wallet/withdrawals, agents, referrals, and the whole email template system (renewal reminders, payments, expiry, welcome). WHEN: wutt audit, check wutt, wutt emails, wutt renewal email, wutt subscription, wutt client pages, wutt packages, welcome email wutt, wutt whatsapp gateway, wutt errors."
collection: Plugsky
category: Platform Ops
license: Plugsky
source: https://plugsky.com/skills
install: "Download the Plugsky skills pack (see below)"
---

# wutt-user-journey

Use when auditing Wutt.net (run your business on WhatsApp & Telegram) — full client onboarding journey, packages/plans and what each client receives, every client-area page, subscriptions and renewals, wallet/withdrawals, agents, referrals, and the whole email template system (renewal reminders, payments, expiry, welcome). WHEN: wutt audit, check wutt, wutt emails, wutt renewal email, wutt subscription, wutt client pages, wutt packages, welcome email wutt, wutt whatsapp gateway, wutt errors.

## Install

```bash
Download the Plugsky skills pack (see below)
```

## Skill

# Wutt.net — full client journey & email audit runbook

Last updated: **2026-10-27** (status review). Full Plugsky audit: `Plugsky/docs/ops/audit-skills.md`.

> **Current status:** the last live Wutt verification was **2026-10-02** (gateway health 9/9, sessions 4 total / 0 connected / 3 disconnected / 1 qr_ready). Wutt was **not re-run** during the 2026-10-27 Plugsky audit. Treat the sections below as the verified runbook; re-run the page harness and gateway health before claiming current Wutt health. The 3 disconnected sessions and 1 qr_ready session still need fresh QR scans.

Wutt.net = Laravel app (multi-language, 18 locales) for running a business on WhatsApp & Telegram:
official Cloud API **and** QR/session gateway, campaigns, templates, chatbots, contacts, inbox,
automation, e-commerce, Wutt Book/Reviews/Loyalty, short links, agents, wallet, plans.

## 0. Access

| Thing | Value |
|---|---|
| Site | `https://wutt.net` · client area `https://wutt.net/user/dashboard` |
| SSH | `ssh -i ~/.ssh/coinplan_deploy -p 65002 u300329072@147.93.92.1` |
| App root | `~/domains/wutt.net/public_html/application` (Laravel) |
| PHP CLI | `/opt/alt/php83/usr/bin/php` (artisan OK) |
| DB | `u300329072_wutt` (creds in `application/.env`; tables: `users`, `pricing_plans`, `plan_purchases`, `notification_templates`, `general_settings`, `whatsapp_accounts`, …) |
| SMTP | stored in DB `general_settings.mail_config` (smtp.hostinger.com:465, support@wutt.net) — **not** in `.env` |
| PM2 | `node ~/nodejs/lib/node_modules/pm2/bin/pm2 list` (apps: `wutt-whatsapp-gateway`, `wutt-watchdog`, `wutt-platform-cron`; config = `application/ecosystem.config.cjs`) |
| Node | user node 20 at `~/nodejs/bin/node` (gateway runtime — do NOT use alt-nodejs24, it OOMs under LVE) |
| Gateway | `http://127.0.0.1:3333` · sessions in `storage/whatsapp-sessions/` · PM2 out/err logs `~/.pm2/logs/wutt-whatsapp-gateway-*.log` |
| Test user | `wutt.audit@example.com` / `WuttAudit123!` (username `wuttaudit`; KYC+2FA flags set; STARTER promo subscription auto-granted by the audit script) |
| Audit harness | `Wutt/tools/wutt_audit_pages.php` (copy to server `/tmp/`, run with php83) |

## 1. Client gate chain (why pages redirect)

Every client page passes through this middleware chain — redirects are *expected* gates, not bugs:

1. `CheckStatus` → needs `status && ev && sv && tv` (else 302 → `/user/authorization`).
2. `RegistrationStep` → needs `users.reg_step = 1` (else 302 → `/user/user/data` complete-profile).
3. `HasSubscription` → needs an active `plan_purchases` row (`expired_at > now`, `payment_status=paid`) for paid pages (else 302 → `/user/subscription/index`).

To audit as a fresh user: set `tv=1, reg_step=1, kv=1` and grant a subscription with
`PurchasePlanController::updateUserSubscription($user, PricingPlan::find(1), 1, Status::WALLET_PAYMENT, 0, null, true)`
(promo → $0, 14 days, no balance impact).

## 2. Packages (pricing_plans — what each client receives)

| id | Plan | Monthly | Yearly | Starter promo | Limits (accounts / telegram / contacts / templates) | Features |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | STARTER | $11 | $70 | **$0 for 14 days** | 5 / 5 / 1,000 / 10 | welcome message, AI assistance, interactive messages, e-commerce, Wutt Book/Reviews/Loyalty |
| 2 | GROWTH | $99 | $540 | $10 for 7 days | 10 / 10 / 5,000 / 10 | + same feature set |
| 3 | UNLIMITED | $299 | $1,200 | $15 for 7 days | 100 / 100 / 50,000 / 100 | + same feature set |

Feature flags live on the plan row (`welcome_message`, `ai_assistance`, `interactive_message`,
`ecommerce_available`, `wutt_book_available`, `wutt_reviews_available`, `wutt_loyalty_available`, …)
and are copied to the user by `updateUserSubscription()`.

## 3. Client-area pages (audit list — all must be 200 for an active user)

WhatsApp: `user.whatsapp.account.index|add`, `user.whatsapp.account.qr.session.start`, `user.whatsapp.webhook.config`
Telegram: `user.telegram.account.index|add` · Templates: `user.template.index|create|sync`
Campaigns: `user.campaign.index|create`, `user.flow.builder.index`
Contacts: `user.contact.list|create`, `user.contactlist.list`, `user.contacttag.list`
Inbox: `user.inbox.list` (+ message send/generate) · Automation: `user.automation.welcome.message`, `user.automation.ai.assistant.setting`
Tools: `user.shortlink.index|plugins`, `user.cta-url.index`, `user.interactive-list.index`, `user.floater.index|plugins`
E-commerce: `user.ecommerce.woocommerce.config`, `user.ecommerce.revenue.index`
Wutt apps: `user.wutt.book.index`, `user.wutt.reviews.index`, `user.wutt.loyalty.index`
Team/API: `user.agent.list|create`, `user.development.credential`, `user.ip.white.list.index`
Wallet: `user.transactions`, `user.withdraw`, `user.withdraw.history` · Billing: `user.subscription.index`, `user.subscription.auto.renewal`
Account: `user.referral.index`, `user.notifications.index`, `user.profile.setting`, `user.twofactor`, `user.change.password`, `user.kyc.form`, `user.authorization`
Dashboard: `user.home` (`/user/dashboard`) · Support: `ticket` (`/ticket`) · Inbox uses `user.inbox.list`, AI assistant `user.automation.ai.assistant`

Run the harness (in-process auth, no captcha):
```bash
scp Wutt/tools/wutt_audit_pages.php u300329072@...:/tmp/
ssh ... '/opt/alt/php83/usr/bin/php /tmp/wutt_audit_pages.php'
```
Expected (2026-09-28): **41/43 pages 200**; `kyc.form` + `authorization` redirect for already-verified users (expected).

## 4. Subscriptions, renewals & cron

- Purchases live in `plan_purchases` (`expired_at`, `recurring_type` 1=monthly 2=yearly, `is_promo`,
  `auto_renewal`, `payment_status`, `is_sent_reminder_notify`).
- Renewal flows in `CronController`:
  - `subscriptionNotify()` → `UPCOMING_EXPIRED_SUBSCRIPTION` (X days before expiry, `gs('subscription_notify_before')`).
    **Fixed 2026-09-28**: it now sets `is_sent_reminder_notify = 1` (previously it repeated daily).
  - expiry → `SUBSCRIPTION_EXPIRED` + zeroes user limits/flags.
  - Stripe renewal failure → `SUBSCRIPTION_RENEWAL_FAILED` (passes `reason`, not `failure_reason`).
- `auto_renewal` toggling: `user.subscription.auto.renewal`.

## 5. Email system

- Processor: `app/Notify/NotifyProcess.php` + `app/Notify/Notify.php`; helper `notify($user, 'ACT', [codes])`
  in `app/Http/Helpers/helpers.php` (auto-adds `site_name`, `site_currency`, `currency_symbol`).
- Global wrapper: `general_settings.email_template` (branded header + `{{message}}` + CTA + footer).
- **Fixed 2026-09-28**: identity short codes (`{{fullname}}`, `{{username}}`) are now replaced inside
  template **bodies** and subjects too (previously only in the wrapper → raw `Hi {{fullname}}` in emails).
- Templates (`notification_templates.act`): WELCOME (id 27, new), UPCOMING_EXPIRED_SUBSCRIPTION (20),
  SUBSCRIPTION_PAYMENT (18), SUBSCRIPTION_EXPIRED (19), SUBSCRIPTION_INVOICE (22, unused),
  SUBSCRIPTION_RENEWAL_FAILED (26), BAL_ADD/SUB, DEPOSIT_*, WITHDRAW_*, PASS_RESET_*, EVER_CODE,
  ADMIN_SUPPORT_REPLY, REFERRAL_COMMISSION, AGENT_REGISTERED. Disabled: TEMPLATE_APPROVE/REJECTED (were "test").
- Welcome email is sent by `RegisterController::register()` after login (notify 'WELCOME': username,
  dashboard_url, subscription_url, login_url).
- Resend manually:
```bash
ssh ... '/opt/alt/php83/usr/bin/php -r \'
require "/home/u300329072/domains/wutt.net/public_html/application/vendor/autoload.php";
$app = require "/home/u300329072/domains/wutt.net/public_html/application/bootstrap/app.php";
$app->make(Illuminate\Contracts\Console\Kernel::class)->bootstrap();
$u = App\Models\User::where("email","USER@EXAMPLE.COM")->firstOrFail();
notify($u, "UPCOMING_EXPIRED_SUBSCRIPTION", ["subscription_type"=>"Monthly","subscription_url"=>route("user.subscription.index"),"plan_name"=>"STARTER","plan_price"=>showAmount(11),"next_billing"=>"28 Sep 2026","post_balance"=>showAmount($u->balance)]);
echo "sent\n";\''
```
- Scripts: `Wutt/tools/wutt_emails.php` (template update — idempotent), `Wutt/tools/wutt_send_tests.php` (render check + send).

## 6. WhatsApp session gateway (RESTORED 2026-10-02 — private Unix socket)

**Status: RUNNING via a private Unix domain socket** (fixed & deployed by ChatGPT 6.1 SOL; documented in
`Wutt/WUTT-GATEWAY-FIX-2026-10-02.md`). The earlier TCP/LVE problem is bypassed:
- `WHATSAPP_SESSION_GATEWAY_SOCKET=<app>/storage/app/whatsapp-gateway.sock` (mode 0600); server.js
  `server.listen(socketPath)` with stale-socket probe + `chmod 0600`; TCP fallback binds `127.0.0.1`.
- Listen-first bootstrap; session restore runs in background after 15s
  (`WHATSAPP_SESSION_RESTORE_ON_BOOT`).
- Laravel `WhatsappSessionGateway.php` uses `CURLOPT_UNIX_SOCKET_PATH`.
- Watchdog: 180 startup attempts, main `~/.pm2` home, `--max-old-space-size=96`.
- Health check: `curl --unix-socket storage/app/whatsapp-gateway.sock http://localhost/health`
  → `{"success":true,"status":"ok","sessions":{...}}`.
- **Still needs humans:** 3 sessions disconnected + 1 `qr_ready` → fresh QR scans; delivery unverified
  until reconnected.

Historical note (2026-09-28, kept for context): the old TCP gateway could not run on this shared host
under the LVE memory ceiling. The socket fix above resolves the reachability problem.

### Legacy TCP-era notes (still useful)
Evidence: the account runs ~10 `lsphp` workers (50–70 MB each ≈ 500–600 MB) plus other services;
with the gateway (85–120 MB) the account hits ~826 MB. Symptoms: the node process binds
(`listening on port 3333`, LISTEN socket present) but then (a) throws
`WebAssembly.instantiate(): Out of memory` (undici) and (b) never accepts connections
(SYN dropped → curl refused/empty). A 24 MB minimal node HTTP server on the same port was
**also unreachable** — proving it is not gateway code. It worked earlier the same day
(11:24, single instance, low account load), which confirms the memory ceiling theory.

Kept fixes (all correct, ready for a host with headroom):
- Watchdog prefers node 20 (`~/nodejs/bin/node`, lower RSS than alt-nodejs24).
- Heap capped: `--max-old-space-size=64 --max-semi-space-size=2`; `WHATSAPP_SESSION_RESTORE_ON_BOOT=false` (lazy sessions — the app resumes stored sessions itself via `whatsapp:gateway-monitor`).
- Crash handlers in `server.js` (uncaughtException/unhandledRejection) so one bad call never kills the process.
- Listen-first bootstrap (HTTP binds before any session restore).
- **Keep the default dual-stack bind** (`app.listen(port)` with no host) — binding to `127.0.0.1`
  explicitly is unreachable under this host's networking; also keep listen pending checks on `127.0.0.1` (works when the process is healthy).
- Do NOT run the gateway under PM2 here (the daemon adds ~56 MB and caused port fights).
  The host's own `hostinger_whatsapp_gateway_supervisor.sh --daemon` + watchdog manage it
  (60s loop, restart-rate cooldown — leave them running; they auto-recover if memory frees).

**VPS migration plan (do this when moving — ~30 min):**
1. On the VPS: copy `whatsapp-gateway/` + `node_modules` (or `npm ci`) and `storage/whatsapp-sessions/` (7 linked dirs, ~9 MB — preserve WhatsApp logins).
2. Run `WHATSAPP_SESSION_GATEWAY_TOKEN=<same token> WHATSAPP_SESSION_GATEWAY_PORT=3333 node whatsapp-gateway/server.js` (node 20+, systemd unit or PM2).
3. Expose it safely: bind to the private network / SSH tunnel, or put it behind nginx with TLS + only allow the Hostinger IP; never expose it token-less publicly.
4. On Hostinger `.env`: set `WHATSAPP_SESSION_GATEWAY_URL=https://<vps-endpoint>` (keep the same `WHATSAPP_SESSION_GATEWAY_TOKEN`).
5. Disable the local supervisor (`pkill -f hostinger_whatsapp_gateway_supervisor`), verify with `php artisan whatsapp:gateway-monitor`, then click **Start QR Session** in the inbox.

**Ops gotchas learned (important for any future debugging):**
- `pkill -f "pattern"` **kills your own SSH command** if the command line contains the pattern —
  use the bracket trick (`pkill -f "[h]ostinger..."`) AND never include the literal path in the same command.
- `/tmp` is mounted **noexec** — helper scripts must live in the app dir.
- Logs cleaned 2026-09-28: `storage/logs` 89 MB → 3.1 MB, `~/.pm2/logs` trimmed, 4 orphan
  session dirs removed (`diag_qr_*`, 3 unlinked `wutt_1_*`), stale dirs archived to `storage/stale-archive-20260928/`.

## 7. Failure playbook

| Symptom | Cause / fix |
|---|---|
| Client page 302 → `/user/authorization` | `users.tv/ev/sv/status` missing → verification gate |
| Client page 302 → `/user/user/data` | `users.reg_step = 0` → profile completion gate |
| Client page 302 → `/user/subscription/index` | no active `plan_purchases` row → subscription gate |
| 500 on `/user/profile/setting` | `users.address` NULL (social signups) — blade uses `$user->address->field`; keep null-safe `?->` |
| Email shows `Hi {{fullname}}` | ensure the NotifyProcess identity fix is present (see §5) |
| Renewal email repeated daily | `is_sent_reminder_notify` not set in `CronController::subscriptionNotify()` |
| Gateway offline | see §6 (host memory ceiling; VPS move plan) |
| SMTP auth fails | `general_settings.mail_config` JSON (host/port/enc/username/password) |

## 8. Session log

- **2026-09-28** — Full audit + fixes:
  - Emails: identity-shortcode bug fixed; branded global wrapper; 5 subscription emails revamped
    (cost shown, CTA buttons, links); WELCOME template created + wired to registration; daily-repeat
    reminder bug fixed; dead "test" templates disabled. Test renewal + welcome sent to
    `bitrixme@gmail.com` (render check: 0 leftover placeholders).
  - Client area: **41/43 pages 200** (2 expected gates); fixed `profile/setting` 500
    (NULL address in blade → `?->`, 5 refs, view cache cleared). Dashboard + Inbox verified 200.
  - Packages documented (§2); gateway: 4 fixes applied, host-level limitation documented (§6).

## 2026-10-02 — Gateway restored (private Unix socket) — read-only audit

- ChatGPT 6.1 SOL fixed & deployed: gateway now on a **0600 Unix domain socket**
  (`storage/app/whatsapp-gateway.sock`), Laravel connects with `CURLOPT_UNIX_SOCKET_PATH`,
  server.js listens first then restores sessions in the background, watchdog hardened
  (180 attempts, main PM2 home, 96 MB heap). Status page: **9/9 checks green**.
- Live health (read-only): `sessions {total:4, connected:0, disconnected:3, qr_ready:1}`.
- Remaining human step: fresh QR scans for 3 logged-out sessions + pair the qr_ready one;
  message delivery unverified until reconnected.
- Revenue snapshot (read-only): gross volume $493 ($252 plan purchases + $241 completed deposits),
  $407 deposits pending/unpaid, $0 withdrawals → actual cash collected ≈ $241; no revenue since
  June 2026 (the Sep-28 $11 row is the audit test user). Full doc:
  `Wutt/WUTT-GATEWAY-FIX-2026-10-02.md`.
- No changes were made to the server in this audit; the 4 live files were pulled into the repo.

## 2026-10-27 — status review (no live re-run)

- This date's audit was **Plugsky-only**. Wutt was not touched, deployed, or re-audited.
- Last known live evidence remains **2026-10-02**: gateway on a 0600 Unix socket, health 9/9, sessions `total:4 / connected:0 / disconnected:3 / qr_ready:1`.
- Before using this skill for a Wutt incident, re-run:
  1. `wutt_audit_pages.php` (expect 41/43 200, 2 expected gates).
  2. Gateway health over the Unix socket.
  3. A read-only plan/subscription query and a test email render.
- Do not claim “Wutt is healthy” from the 2026-10-02 snapshot. The gateway sessions still need human QR scans; delivery is unverified until reconnected.
- Cross-reference: `Plugsky/docs/ops/audit-skills.md` §1 (OpenCode skills) and §11 (remaining risks).

## 2026-11-16 — trial incident, support, security, full audit

**Reported:** `gauravisonline@gmail.com` (user 43, Google signup 13 Nov) could not start the free trial; every paid page redirected with “You do not have an active plan”. Support ticket #407143 was opened 15 Nov and unanswered.

**Root cause (fixed):** `pricing_plans` STARTER has `promo_enabled=1`, `promo_price=0`, `promo_days=14`, but `PricingPlan::hasStarterPromo()` required `promo_price > 0`, so the $0 trial was rejected. The `store()` free branch also called `updateUserSubscription()` without `isPromo`, which would have charged the full $11 if it ever ran. Admin validation rejected a $0 promo, and the button rendered “Start $0.00 Promo”.

**Fixes deployed (backups in `~/wutt-hotfix-20261116/backup`):**
- `app/Models/PricingPlan.php` — allow `promo_price >= 0` (null still rejected); same for annual promo.
- `app/Http/Controllers/User/PurchasePlanController.php` — free branch passes `coupon` + `isPromo`; free trial records amount 0, 14-day expiry, no wallet debit.
- `app/Http/Controllers/Admin/PricingPlanController.php` + `resources/views/admin/plans/index.blade.php` — allow/save a 0 promo and label it as a free trial.
- `resources/views/presets/default/sections/plan.blade.php` — “Start 14-day free trial” when promo price is 0.
- `bootstrap/app.php` + `app/Http/Controllers/User/ProfileController.php` — `AuthenticateSession` on the web group, `logoutOtherDevices()` + remember-token rotation on password change (fixes the emailed security report). Redirect callback handles `admin*` → `admin.login`, everything else → `user.login`.
- `config/app.php` + `app/Notify/Email.php` — admin support replies CC `config('app.support_ticket_cc')`, default `mustafa@valu.vc` (SMTP path). Verified with a live `Cc:` header.
- `resources/views/admin/user_data/contact_list.blade.php` — null-safe user for 6 orphan contact lists (user 16 deleted) that 500'd the admin page.
- `routes/admin.php` — removed dead `request/report` routes (methods no longer exist).
- `app/Http/Controllers/Admin/FrontendController.php` + `public/assets/presets/default/preview.jpg` — initialize `$templates`, use `resource_path()`, serve the preview from public assets.
- `routes/web.php` — register `glossary/{slug}` before `{country}/whatsapp-crm`; the country wildcard swallowed `/glossary/whatsapp-crm` (sitemap 404).
- `app/Http/Helpers/helpers.php` — `getTemplates()` uses `request()->getSchemeAndHttpHost()` instead of `$_SERVER['HTTP_HOST']`.

**Data actions (16 Nov 2026):**
- User 43 granted STARTER trial via `updateUserSubscription(..., isPromo: true)`: `plan_purchases` id 13, amount 0, 14 days, expires **2026-11-30 18:58 UTC**, balance unchanged.
- Ticket 22 (#407143) replied and emailed; status answered (1). Reply includes trial end date and setup links.
- Guest ticket 23 created for the emailed session-invalidation report; acknowledgment emailed to `dank83382@gmail.com`, CC `mustafa@valu.vc`.
- QA user 36 granted a trial until 2026-11-30 so the page harness can run.

**Verification:**
- Client area: **41/43 200** (the 2 redirects are the expected `kyc.form` / `authorization` gates for a verified user).
- Admin area: **51/51 200** (request/report now 404 because the dead route was removed).
- Public sitemap: **302/302 200**; landing page and pricing modal 0 console errors in the in-app browser. Trial modal shows `STARTER · 0.00 USD · 14 days promo`.
- PHP lint: **355/355 files clean**; all Blade templates compile.
- Support reply email: SMTP accepted, `notification_logs` row created; CC test showed `To: support@wutt.net | Cc: mustafa@valu.vc`.

**Open findings (not fixed):**
1. `support@wutt.net` IMAP inbox is not ingested into tickets. Real emails (security report 16 Nov, two sales emails) never appeared in `support_tickets`; 19 spam tickets remain open and no admin had ever replied (`support_messages.admin_id = 0` on all 19).
2. WhatsApp: gateway runtime is healthy (Unix socket, `/health` ok) but **0 connected sessions**. 8 QR sessions: 5 waiting_qr, 1 qr_ready, 2 disconnected. No Cloud API accounts. Status page says “Messaging delivery online” while no session is authenticated — it measures runtime, not session connectivity.
3. Copy mismatch: ~286 sitemap pages say “$1 trial”; the actual offer is a $0 14-day trial (55 pages say “free trial”). A global content pass is needed.
4. Gateway runs on `/opt/alt/alt-nodejs24` (node 24) with a 96 MB heap; previously node 20 was recommended to avoid LVE OOM. Watchdog is a shell process, PM2 list is empty (gateway/cron are supervised outside PM2).
5. Historical `SQLSTATE[HY000] [2002] Operation not permitted` errors (508 on 2026-11-14 08:xx) still need a root-cause check; no recurrence on 16 Nov.

### 2026-11-16 — $0 / 14-day copy pass (approved)

Approved offer: **$0 for 14 days**, then $11/month Starter (auto-renewal on, no payment method required for the trial).

- Rewrote every public trial claim: `$1 trial`, `$1 first-month trial`, `$1 first month`, `$1 Wutt trial`, “before you pay more than a dollar”, the “Start for $1 Trail” typo, the homepage hero key `hero.cta.start` (“Start 1$ Trial”), and the Arabic CTA “جرّب Wutt لمدة $1”.
- Static files: 17 content/Blade files under `resources/content` and `resources/views/presets/default` (compare, guides, products, reviews, trust, countries, news, case-studies, pricing-teardowns, case_study, review, switch, compare_roundup, pricing_teardown, blog_details, plan section).
- DB `frontends` rows updated: `1` (SEO description + social description), `102` (home CTA button), `112–116`, `136–137`, `186–193`, `194`, `195`, `196`, `200–201` (blog/CTA/price tables). `$29/mo` Wutt table cells corrected to `$11/mo`.
- `app/Services/WuttSeoBlogPublisher.php` (live copy) generator defaults changed from `Start $1 trial` to the 14-day wording; `'Starts from'` changed from `$29/mo` to `$11/mo`.
- `resources/views/presets/default/blog_details.blade.php` ROI cost changed from `$29` to `$11`.
- Verification: 302/302 sitemap URLs 200; **0 pages** with a `$1` trial/first-month/dollar promise; landing + pricing 0 console errors; client 41/43 (2 expected gates); admin 51/51; Blade compile passes.

**Cache trap:** the SEO head reads `Cache::get('frontend_seo_data')` with a 6-hour TTL (`AppServiceProvider`). After changing `frontends` `seo.data`, always run:

```bash
php artisan cache:clear
php -r '... Cache::forget("frontend_seo_data");'
```

Otherwise the homepage keeps the old meta description and OG description.

**Specs written:**
- `Wutt/docs/specs/email-to-ticket-ingestion-2026-11-16.md`
- `Wutt/docs/specs/whatsapp-qr-session-cleanup-2026-11-16.md`

## Notes

Listed by Plugsky. Skill text and behaviour belong to the upstream author.
If you redistribute it, keep the upstream license and attribution.
